Ask any experienced personal injury attorney about whether using medical images enhances his or her ability to illustrate a complex story to the jury and you will get a resounding agreement. But if you ask them how difficult it is to make that happen, you will find that most pause, unsure of how to proceed.
When trying to get a jury to understand the causal relationship and the impact of a physical injury, clear evidence is paramount. Traditionally, this evidence has relied heavily on medical records, witness testimonies, and expert opinions. However, recent advancements in medical imaging technology have significantly shifted this landscape. Actual medical images provided during discovery and increasingly displayed (often electronically) at trial are becoming a critical component in of medical injury cases, providing compelling, objective evidence that can decisively influence the outcome of litigation. This blog explores how and why medical images are becoming indispensable in medical injury litigation.
1. The Power of Visual Evidence
Medical images, including X-rays, MRIs, CT scans and ultrasounds, offer a visual representation of the human body’s internal structures. Unlike written records, these images provide a clear, very graphic, objective view of an injury, its severity and its progression over time. This visual evidence can be crucial in establishing a causal link between the medical treatment received and the injury sustained.
For example, in cases of alleged medical malpractice involving surgical errors, an MRI can reveal damage to internal organs that might not be adequately documented in surgical notes. Similarly, in personal injury cases resulting from accidents, CT scans can demonstrate the extent of trauma to the brain or other vital structures, supporting claims of long-term disability or pain.
2. Enhancing Expert Testimony
Expert testimony is a cornerstone of medical injury litigation. Medical professionals provide opinions on whether the standard of care was breached and if that breach directly caused or contributed to harm. Medical images enhance these testimonies by offering concrete visual evidence that an expert can literally point to, to support the expert’s conclusions.
Experts can use medical images to illustrate their points more effectively to a jury, who usually do not have a medical background. For instance, an orthopedic surgeon explaining the misalignment of a fractured bone can show an X-ray to the jury, making the explanation more comprehensible and compelling. This visual aid can bridge the gap between complex medical jargon and the layperson's understanding, thereby strengthening the case.
The continual advancements in medical imaging technology have played a pivotal role in their growing importance in litigation. High-resolution images, 3D reconstructions, and functional imaging techniques offer unprecedented clarity and detail. These advancements enable a more accurate assessment of injuries and medical conditions.
For example, 3D reconstructions of CT scans, like the screen shot below, allow for a comprehensive view of complex fractures or internal injuries, which can be rotated and examined from multiple angles. This level of detail can reveal nuances that might be missed in traditional 2D images or reproduced images, providing a more thorough understanding of the injury's impact.
4. The Role of Imaging in Proving
Causation and Damages
In medical injury litigation, proving causation—that a healthcare provider's negligence directly caused the injury—is often challenging. Medical images can provide the critical link needed to establish causation. They offer objective evidence that can link specific medical procedures with subsequent injuries.
Additionally, medical images are instrumental in proving damages. They can document the severity of injuries, the need for ongoing treatment, and the presence of permanent disability. This documentation is essential for quantifying the compensation required for medical expenses, pain and suffering, and loss of income.
Challenges and Considerations
While the introduction of medical images in litigation offers numerous benefits, it also presents challenges. The use of medical images in litigation requires a nuanced understanding that blends legal acumen with a grasp of medical science. While many attorneys are proficient in leveraging these images as part of their case strategies, their ability to do so effectively can vary.
The admissibility of medical images in court relies on the proper authentication and establishment of their relevance to the case. Legal teams must ensure that the images are obtained and handled in compliance with legal standards to avoid disputes over their validity. Understanding the DICOM tag system can contribute to the attorney’s ability to succeed in getting these images entered into evidence.
Conclusion
As medical imaging technology continues to evolve, its role in medical injury litigation is expanding. Effective attorneys use medical images as part of their visual storytelling strategy. They integrate these images into presentations, using software to highlight key aspects and create visual aids that enhance the jury's understanding.
As image resolution continues to increase, image views become more compelling. The ability of medical images to provide clear, objective, and detailed evidence makes them invaluable in proving causation, enhancing expert testimony, and documenting damages. While challenges remain, the benefits of incorporating medical images into litigation strategies are undeniable. As such, legal professionals should stay current with technological advancements, acquire the tools and develop the expertise necessary to utlize medical images effectively in their cases.
Medical images are more than just diagnostic tools—they are becoming key pieces of evidence that can make or break a case, underscoring their growing importance in the pursuit of justice in medical injury litigation.
Want to learn more?
Register for the Three-Part Summer Series:
Incorporating Medical Imaging into Litigation 101
or reach out to us with your questions!
